Dear Ganesan In general you can qualify welder and welding operator and the procedure with both standards, but about 6GR that is defined in AWD D1.1, this position covers all other positions, but in ASME Sec. IX because you shall mention this position as a special position, the qualification range will be just this position. About the testing according to ASME and AWS, test description and dimension are the same. You have to care just about ranges of qualifications. Regards On Tue, Aug 30, 2011 at 5:13 PM, Ganesan Nallathamby < ganesan6133@hotmail.com > wrote: Dear Experts I'm not sure if either AWS D1.1 and/or ASME Sect. IX ( both year 2010 )prohibits using PQR qualified to other codes. However ASME do not have any provision for 6GR Position but only recognize "special position" in QW-303.3. According to AWS D1.1-Note "d" in Table 4.10 & Note "c" in Table 4.1-PQT Pls refer attached AWS Interpretation I need all you gu...
Materials selection, welding, forming, Heat treatment, corrossion, NDT